Skip to main content

The Resource Curse

I read a really interesting article in Knowledge@Wharton about what is called "The Resource Curse". It's an economic paradox in which countries that have substantial natural resource reserves, particularly in petroleum and natural gas, are actually worse off as a result compared to countries that do not have those reserves. The article primarily focuses on African nations that are major oil exporters or where recent oil reserves have been discovered. The cause of the paradox seems to be several fold (these are my conclusions from the article):
  • Over-valued currency leads to decrease in exports - The export of oil greatly inflates the value of the country's currency, causing any other exported item to be uncompetitive in the global marketplace. Agriculture, manufacturing, or most other industries are at a severe disadvantage compared to neighboring countries. This has a substantial impact on the average, every-day African citizen.

  • Single industry economy leads to atrophy of traditional industries - Because of the booming petroleum business, workers flock to that industry leaving all other industries short on labor. Traditional industries like agriculture are decimated. Combined with over-valued currency, you end up with a single-industry economy where you import everything but energy resources. In the short-run this might seem ok, but all of these oil reserves will eventually run dry at some point. At that time, all of the other industries in the country will have atrophied, leaving the country with few industries to fall back on.

  • Corruption leads to lack of internal investment - Oil companies are more than happy to pay their fair share of taxes and kick-backs. Politicians end up vying for these dollars instead of worrying about their constituencies. With a government essentially funded by the oil companies and not funded by income taxes from the general population, the politicians have little incentive to serve their constituents in the short or long-term. In addition, at the time when oil reserves are discovered in most of these countries, their social and political systems are extremely immature. They don't yet have the checks and balances in place to understand how to deal with opportunity. Instead of providing a nudge to mature quicker, infusing huge amounts of cash into the economy likely hinders maturity because there is, again, little incentive for politicians or citizens to do worry about structural improvements in systems like education or infrastructure.

It's a pretty fascinating paradox when you think about. But I'm sure it's not one without parallels in other areas. For instance, politically, can you take Iraq, a country that has been ruled by a dictator for two or three decades, and within the course of several years turn it into a democracy? And then economically, can you take Russia, a country that has for decades relied on a command or centrally controlled economy, and expect it to change and sustain an open-market economy? (Is it that surprising that they are bringing several industries back under state control?) I think generally speaking there's a lesson here about globalization and the pace of change that economies can really capitalize on. If the basic systems are not in place to balance out an economy and sustain opportunity, any benefits from political reform, economic reform, or new investment will be fleeting.
Labels:

Comments

Post a Comment

Popular posts from this blog

Dancing on the Edge of a Volcano

I found this opinion piece ( Democrats aren't innocent bystanders ) interesting on how both Democrats and Republicans share responsibility for polarizing the electorate and undermining some of its faith in democracy. It references two other posts that were pretty good as well: The Disease of Delegitimization The Weimarization of the American Republic The second article is really long and heavy on history.  But given all of the comparisons people make between the current times and those of post-WWI Germany, I found it interesting to dive in to understand where the comparisons are coming from and how close we really are.  The short answer is that we aren't that close (phew). Seems like post-WWI Germany was incredibly fragile.  This was a good excerpt that summarized it: So, unlike the 60s, you have a dynamic in which both sides are behaving like radicals, in which the establishment isn’t yelling “stop,” and in which oikophobia is more evenly distributed, relative to its Boo...
Post a Comment
Read more

The Four Steps to the Epiphany and the Customer Development Model

When I visited FlightCaster over spring break as part of the Duke Week-in-Cities trip, Jason Freedman (founder and CEO) suggested that we all read The Four Steps to the Epiphany by Steve Blank . FlightCaster went through the YCombinator program in 2009 and from what I gathered the book was required reading. I had never even heard of it and it was required reading! I just finished it and I certainly understand why that's the case now. I have to admit the book wasn't necessarily what I expected. It certainly wasn't product management 101. It turned out to be much more about navigating the start-up process rather than specifics about how to design great products. But I can't believe I almost missed out on this one. The book outlines the Customer Development model, a parallel technique to product development that is meant to guide you in the process of iterating and testing each part of your business model until you find one that is repeatable and scalable. The m...
Post a Comment
Read more

Nine Prescriptions for Building the Duke Entrepreneurial Community

I think Duke can have one of the strongest entrepreneurial communities in the world. Are we there yet? Well, not yet. But there's a tremendous amount of momentum that I saw build in just the past two years while I was getting my MBA at Duke. While leading Duke's 10th annual business plan competition, the Duke Start-Up Challenge (DSC) , last year, I witnessed a near doubling of participation on campus in just a single year. The interest on the ground was clearly there and building rapidly. But now that I'm an alum, I'm looking back and wondering ... how do we rev-up the Duke entrepreneurial community even more? I read a great article by Daniel Isenberg, a professor of management at Babson, called " How to Start an Entrepreneurial Revolution " in the June edition of the Harvard Business Review. Isenberg outlines nine prescriptions for governments that want to create entrepreneurship ecosystems in their countries. Although he was focused on governments an...
3 comments
Read more